Saturday, March 2, 2013

A Commentary on Budget 2013


There is a lot of hue and cry over the Budget 2013.  There are a lot of contentious articles blaming Finance Minister of putting huge burden on the middle class. I am just trying to think aloud of FM’s rationale behind this.

Let us start with the basic question, what comprises this “Middle Class?” A broad income based classification, brings forth three classes: lower class, middle class and upper class. As per Tendulkar’s Committee report, population below poverty line is 29.8%1, say ambitiously assuming, 2% of population are rich, which in this case, earning over 1 crore per annum. This gives middle class share to be around 68.2%.

Our FM has put up a surcharge of 10% for this 2% rich population. Government is bound to undertake welfare programs for this lower 29.8%2 segment because they are poor. So how righteous is it to say that he should also exempt this huge chunk of 68.2%, when tax collection is the major source of revenue for government to carry out various planned and unplanned expenditures. Of course being reasonable, he has further classified this middle class into upper middle class and lower middle class and has tried to take appropriate measures for liberalizing the lower middle class by giving them tax exemption of Rs 2000 for income below Rs 5,00,000 p.a. and has tried to rope in the upper middle class to compensate. Now isn’t his basis looks justified from an equity argument, which is the fundamental role of any government. Further, we should also think from a national interest, considering that country is under a fiscal deficit of 5.2%. 

The basis which FM has tried to undertake for selecting this upper middle class are those who eat in Air Conditioned hotels, those who travel in cars, those who use expensive mobile phones and accordingly he has tried to levy taxes on those fronts. Isn’t it reasonable?

1These population figures are estimates from 2010.
2I am being too generous in saying, welfare schemes for only 29.8%, when World Bank report 68.7% Indian population earning less than Rs 40,000 p.a. based on purchasing power parity. 

Friday, March 1, 2013

Too Much Care is Poison



Excess care cripples the inner strength of the cared person. Reason is simple. Suppose I am caring guy, so I would like to provide as much care as possible to my loved one, many times eliminating the room for risk taking by her. Such actions, over time, prove hazardous for the cared person, as she loses the skill of taking decisions and being responsible for her decisions. It is also a form of slavery.  

Indian Society is full of numerous such families. Females are treated as objects of sympathy and care, starting within home. They hardly participate in decision making chores and mostly are advised. They are dependent on male members or elderly women, who try to play maximum safe. So to buy a pencil/grocery, a girl would consult within the family and may be her brother or father would buy it for her. One should understand that small things like these are ground bearers to face the real world tomorrow. Depriving girls of such initial opportunities, in the name of protection and too much care, obstructs gradual building of inner courage and could be a plausible reason of their fragile confidence. There is little stress situation and females panic, look helpless, seeking a helping hand. 

We all admire and praise a bold girl, but simultaneously one should also look at the attributes that led her grow like that. So, care should be of constructivist nature which brothers, sisters, husbands, wives, boyfriends, girlfriends, fathers, mothers and all responsible adults should understand. Excess care is Poison!

Sunday, January 27, 2013

Life of a Mediocre



A mediocre is a person who doubts his decisions. He is another cog in the wheel. And the world forms the similar opinion about him. An achiever is confident of his words and decisions. And the world forms similar opinion about him.

A mediocre makes compromises everyday. I am doing this, is it right? I am thinking to do that, what will be the outcome? Will the people appreciate it? One loses the ability to make decisions, and develops a tendency to continue doing the routine job. He makes constant efforts to bring perfection to the routine job, as it is a human characteristic to prove one’s metal. Of course, a pondering issue is where to apply effort for maximum leverage.  

I was reading Swami Vivekananda a few days back, he philosophy was so fundamental and obvious. He said one should respect one’s parents and wife and ensure that they are satisfied and happy with you. Further he added that a person should follow his heart, including the desire to earn money, as it is equally relevant for societal welfare as any social action, but only after keeping parents and wife in good faith. So true and logical! Being a leader means having faith on oneself, understanding and enacting on the fundamental logics. In fact, fundamental things should be an integral part of life, not like each time I listen something, I ask myself, is it aligned to the fundamental?

A basic difference between, an achiever and a mediocre during a conversation is that, an achiever tries to build up his arguments keeping in mind that they are coherent with the basic logics, while a mediocre put up a popular, listened/read view, without giving much thought about his personal agreement or disagreement with it. Hence, whilst an achiever takes a stand while a mediocre just recites a popular view, and his stand is not firm. And this is how leaders and followers are born!

Sunday, January 20, 2013

Learning English Language



Today I met Sonia ma’am from a progressive school in Delhi. She does English language with children from KG till standard 5. She has an interesting way of teaching. Actually she involves children in the activities like story telling, expressing different emotions, motivating them for writing their feeling after an activity. The active School teacher- Language teacher, making children learn English through senses. Like she gets chips, then asks them to write how it tasted, how it felt- sour, so what is sour, show it emotionally, what other words are possible for sour. 

Story making… say with flexible wires… she started making roads and converted into railway tracks and then asked somebody to make spectacles and so on, the story unfolds….
Similarly she asks children to create graphic novel…

This way through, lot of theatres, tastes, senses, emotions etc. she does language with the children. What a fantastic way!

Grumpy- show me grumpy… in another way, what other emotion can be put for grumpy. She also does story telling and even after doing a story for 50 times, she again re-reads it, before doing, and tries to do it in a new way, so there is continuous learning happening, with each new time reading with the group.

Wednesday, January 16, 2013

दिल की बात


कुछ दिनों से आत्म मंथन चल रहा है,
सोच के पीछे की सोच समझने पर मंथन चल रहा है|
इन सब के बीच, हर वक़्त मुस्कराते रहने की कोशिश जारी है,
हम पागल नहीं हैं, समझ चुके हैं हमारी क्या बीमारी है| 


Tuesday, April 3, 2012

A note on Summer Internship for my Economics friends

The best internship is the one you have got currently. Go for it! In case you don’t have an intern till now or you are uncertain what to do and trying to explore, read further.

My attempt is to give a broad idea of different possibilities which you can opt for, both conventional and unconventional. These are based on what I have realized overtime.

Before beginning, I would like to say that in general Economists are few (with Economists, I mean certified ones) and only large companies hire them (one, two or may be three) full time. Yes, there are lots of analysts in the firms and their role is to implement, test and improve, the economic models developed by economists, of their own firm or by economics/finance/statistics professors working in universities. So, in general, the internships to undergrads offered in large firms are of testing the models. Same is the kind of internships in universities. You will be required to do data collection, filtering, and fitting onto the model and verifying it. This is obvious, as any model development needs conceptualization for which Economists are needed, and you are still not one (certified!) so you are less trustworthy. Also economic institutions are a few and all budding economists want to go there as these are the names that come first when the Google keywords like "Economics," "Internship," "training," "Finance," and naturally fourth year would be preferred over third and third over second. So, in case your seniors have not found an intern yet, and you have one, Trust me you are Very Lucky!

These are the general internship work descriptions that are done in conventional economics firms or universities. Some students do get path breaking internships where they work actually as economists. But here, I wish to write for the junta who either have mailed a lot by now and received several rejections or want to do something practical during their holidays or are quite frustrated learning there neighbors have their summers engaged and they are still jobless.

Don't be "koop-manduk" in thinking about Economics internships as the ones related to Demand-Supply or Finance or Policy research only. In the rush of applying, what we forget is that Economics is much more than conventional centers. In fact any recent economic activity is highly interdisciplinary, like socio-economic, behavioral economics, health-care economics, and neural economics. Some places where economics is happening are in design department, hotels, shops, e-commerce, advertisement industry, start-ups, small firms, SMEs operating in any sector, journalism both print and media, NGOs, etcetera. In short, wherever balance sheet is involved and there is cash-flow, a budding economist has ample opportunity to observe the activity, try plotting/quantifying it on paper to come up with a pattern/plot. This is how any real life modeling is done. To do this, all that one needs, is an elementary micro and macro courses and a keen sense of observation and patience to think of various permutations and combinations to come up with a pattern (even no pattern is a pattern) at different levels macro or micro. Just wear your Economics Lenses.

To elaborate on my point, say how you fit in a Design place. They work on product development. You can have a crucial role to play by finding out about potential market, product pricing, fund allocation for advertisement, product development, operations, credit facility, patent procedure and so on. These are important areas on which they anyways have to work, even in the absence of an economist. So, you can have a vital role to play over there and your work will be respected as well because any day you are better than a non-trained person. Even at a micro level, you can be at the shop floor and understand the purchasing behaviour of customers by changing the location and visibility of product from the counter, or cuisines order in restaurants to find a pattern in ordering preference. The advantage at such a place is that they would always want to maximize their sales but can never hire a certified Economist. In Economics discipline, the best jobs today are the ones where the economists are building models. And in unconventional places, you will have this opportunity. Even a good and relevant research in university today, involves surveys and data collection from the people.

Such an internship opportunity would develop one, a practical market experience for you and second, a niche specialization of that industry where you can always apply off-campus for job.

Some further scopes are like working with a corporate lawyer, even just sitting with him teaches a lot. Tourism service provider firms are also wonderful both in terms of adventure and economic learning scope of tourism industry. Internet policy research and censoring information are also potential fields.

Wherever money exchange is involved, one has an opportunity to learn economics. It is all about analyzing the phenomenon around you with Economic Lenses. Say for example, your Canteen.... there is practically all economics and strategy making is applied everyday by the Canteen-wale bhaiya, to sell his products.

This article by Hal Varian is a good starting point: http://people.ischool.berkeley.edu/~hal/Papers/how.pdf

Saturday, January 29, 2011

Internship this Summer

I am an Undergraduate at IIT Kanpur(I know it's a ridiculous start.. :|) struggling hard to get an Internship position at any Financial firm in the coming summer'11(what better can one expect in my current puzzled state?). I am still not sure why am I doing it. Am I really interested in becoming a financial analyst or a stock trader, I REALLY don't know...!!! Then why the hell am I looking for such an internship?

Oviously, I am doing it just to impress my future employers. Do I know them? No, I don't know them, but I feel, this credential added to my resume would arouse their interest in me and I would get a job in that "XYZ" firm. What a satisfying reason for my endeavour! Huh...BULLSHIT...!!!

On the contrary, just the idea of following my passion about exploring the world around in vacation Always elevates my mood. But will I do that? How could I? Won't it undervalue my position amongst my peer competitors? Wouldn't it lower my chances of reaching the asses of my would be interviewers?

No, no I won't do that. I am continuing my efforts of being an intern in a Financial Firm untill I have the COURAGE TO FOLLOW MY HEART.